In Search of NEW-CLEAR-PEACE DHEEL- The real side of the nuclear Deal

Well it was a pretty dull week this one for me! Not exactly for the govt. while our beloved peaceful phlegmatic P.M was giving sleepless nights to the communists and as I search for some peace, Media has finally got its own piece of news for the week and left Aarushi to rest in peace. While Americans hiding behind the Bush! Are going to push India forward for peaceful nuclear power and give it a piece of the nuclear fuel, I have been searching for my own piece of luck (not peace).

Well the new-clear-peace that I’ve been searching for I’ve not found! I’m confused. Drop it! Let us focus on national issues, being true Indians we should always discuss, call meetings (and get people confused) arouse people’s sentiments (Amarnath Shrine Board Incident and Indore riots) after all we need to discuss (and not do anything, Communists in India, talk, brag, bully and more importantly do not join the government but just support from outside. Is that what the public voted for (na i did not vote i wasn’t 18 then), come on go make our policies, not just oppose them, owe responsibility for what’s going on!) India is on the development path and is soon going to overtake the US in terms of GDP. But will that be simple! No I guess if we just keep discussing and not act!

MAIN AREA OF CONCERN:  as we develop so will our energy demands grow sky high (well really? Yes). The major chunk of electricity that we produce is through our thermal plants, which consumes millions of tonnes of coal to convert steam energy into electricity and at the same time release that much amount of CO2 in the environment (not a great idea right). In future our energy demands are going to rise so much that we will not only exhaust our own coal but will have to import it (provided it’s left anywhere in the world) and imagine what threat to the world we will be guzzling out carbon to the atmosphere. Now why is nuclear energy so important? First coal is not a clean fuel; it is exhaustible in near future. Moreover there are ways to utilize non conventional sources like wind, ocean etc. but scope is limited and it’s difficult for it to directly sustain all the demands. So we turn to nuclear fuel particularly due to it being clean, limited but highly efficient, large scale power generation!

What seems “Left” is not Right? Well meet our communist friends; they have been pulling the poor Sardar’ leg ever since he went behind the Bush and gave an impression of being the new Mr. Tony Blair. According to the revered Economist (because of whom millions are working in the IT industry, People are going gaga over shopping branded stuff at the malls and enjoying the same status as the Americans in America) India is enjoying best ever relationship with Uncle Sam. And now it has become such a good friend that it is giving all this stuff for free (has to be a great friend indeed) Nuclear energy technology which Indians can use and take away all those jobs from Americans (Reason why OBAMA is against this deal!) How?  Look it will light up all the villages in India, then they will also get connected to broadband, then these IT companies will train the farmers in C, C++ and make them code for the Firangis in the west (look open source volunteers, farming in the morning, code in the night all voluntarily, that is how free software and open source community came along selling pizzas @ day and coding @ night giving Mr. Gates sleepless nights a.k.a NO PEACE @ all). Or some BPO fellows will setup a call centre, train our farmers in English and make them sell airline tickets for United Airlines! Everything is possible, Impossible is Nothing (courtesy: ADIDAS).

Coming back to our communist friends, they say that the govt. did not divulge all the details of the deal and there is a hidden agenda! Ah-ha! They feel that this deal is going to affect the sovereignty of the country and India may be headed the Pakistan way obliging the US. Moreover putting the atomic reactors under safeguards will put an end to future developments and advancements in nuclear technology. They also say that the sudden rise in the oil prices is due to US playing dirty games for getting countries like India to worry and fall into the nuclear trap! (courtesy Russia, Saudi and Iran, top three oil producers saying there is no fuel shortage and there will be no decrease in supply) point I guess!

Why they are not right?

1. India’s reactors running at half the capacity due to unavailability of fuel, uranium in this case.

2. India’s growing energy demand and future requirements indicate towards cleaner efficient fuel.

3. Only nuclear reactors which are used for civilian power generation under safeguards and not all, moreover the fuel will be tracked and monitored by IAEA only in these reactors and not all of them, so we can still manage to make bombs and scare off Pakistan! (Though not a bright idea again, India is a country that always preaches Peace, (PEACE again!) Pakis are our bro’s right).

Infact the 123 agreement and under the IAEA and NSG approval will allow India to use nuclear technology under dual use (Dual-use technologies earn their name because they can be used for both military and civilian purposes. Since India is under Nuclear Suppliers’ Group (NSG) sanctions, such technologies are denied to the country even for civilian use for fear they may be covertly used for military purposes.) Like:

Hidden gains

Sports gear: Lightweight and unbreakable tennis rackets, golf clubs and fishing poles.X-ray machines: Medical and dental imaging machines using radioactive cobalt-60.Space prog: Latest in telemetry, propulsion, guidance, speciality materials, nanotech.Defence sector: Components for developing a defence system against Pakistan’s rocket arsenal.






The reason: the hi-tech fibres and filaments often used to make lightweight and unbreakable tennis rackets, golf clubs and fishing poles can also be used in the uranium-enrichment process. Also affected by the various sanctions are medical and dental imaging machines that use radioactive cobalt-60 and similar substances. Advanced technologies used to make ammonia and fertiliser can also be used to make heavy water.

Ultra low-speed photography equipment, pressure-measuring instruments and some types of communications switching equipment are also banned.

The famous supercomputer ban imposed by the US in the early 1990s was also a consequence of such sanctions. Sales of Sony’s Play Station 2 to India were under a cloud because the gaming device fell under Japanese dual-use export controls. NSG sanctions lie behind the recent arrest of Indian scientists trying to buy heat-resistant silicon chips in the US. All these and a host of other tech barriers will disappear if the nuclear deal is completed: a benefit of de facto nuclear club membership.

US commerce department and Indian industry representatives say the biggest problem with technology sanctions is the “uncertainty principle”. Technology evolves faster than the sanctions written to control their export. It isn’t uncommon for an Indian request for technology to be turned down because a US official, befuddled by an archaic rules book, decides not to take chances. The 123 Agreement would mean the official would give India the benefit of the doubt.

4. There’s nothing like compromising with security, it’s only about managing and understanding your needs, moreover there’s nothing wrong by sticking to a strong partner, I don’t understand how it is going to affect our sovereignty! As long as US is not asking for an airbase to attack China, or send Indian troops to Iran, India should be fine with it. Ok we blow another bomb for a Test and the deal is scrapped, come on we are looking at realistic situations here.  I was reading that we won’t be able to test nuclear bombs that can be sent on a missile to beijing, drop it. why? the next point answers

5. In this globalized world we are looking towards interdependence. China has it’s huge population to feed, it’s main strength is export and majority to the US. All of US’s IT work is done in INDIA. do you think it will see it’s two biggest suppliers of human resource, IT, manufactured goods, Hardware, food grains, soaps, Tooth Paste etc. bomb each other. what about the people in the US, they will struggle, their lives will be greatly affected! coming down to the worst scenario of a war, if ever a war is there between India and China then i don’t think there will be any force left to rule, cos the world wouldn’t be existing! so let us just forget that such a thing would happen and be realistic.

6. We are developing breeder reactors which will run on thorium but it will take time in R&D, so by that time we can fulfill our requirements through this new deal.( we have thorium in abundance, ever been to kerala!)

7. Moreover going ahead with this deal does not entitle India to buy fuel or technology only from  the US, there are 45 countries in the Nuclear supplier groups and India can approach any of them for any technology for civilian nuclear power, so why the fuss? France has already come out in support and so has Russia to supply the necessary technology.

With reference to the above points I really don’t see any reason why the communists are opposing it? Are they so averse to any foreign technology? Or to the capitalistic US? Or are they just non-committed towards the people of India? The larger picture has to be seen not in case of the political scenario but also the long term needs. And while I finish this it seems Aarushi has finally found peace (CBI seems to have figured out the culprit), but I’m still to find mine!


 P.S: The opinion is purely of the author’s and should be seen as just another way of expressing oneself in this democracy and means no offences to any party or ideology!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s